Many of these songs are on here thanks to the amazing sparrowsarahnade who has the most comprehensive collection of Dean/Cas themed songs I have ever seen. Mine pales in comparison. But here it it nonetheless! I’ve tried to keep them alphabetical by song title :)

• Accidentally In Love - Counting Crows

• All You Did Was Save My Life - Our Lady Peace

• Almost Lover - A Fine Frenzy
• Amazing - Aerosmith
• Angel - Nine Inch Nails
• Angel - Aerosmith
• Angels - Within Temptation
• The Angels Hung Around - Rilo Kiley
• Angels Losing Sleep - Our Lady Peace
• Ant Farm - Eels
• Anything Goes - Guns N’ Roses
• Apologize - OneRepublic
• The Archer’s Bows Are Broken - Brand New
• Armour Love - La Roux
• As Long As It Takes - The Spill Canvas
• As Lovers Go - Dashboard Confessionals
• Back to December - Taylor Swift
• Back to Hell - Alkaline Trio
• Bad Romance - Lady Gaga OR 30 Seconds to Mars
• Bad Things - Jace Everett
• Bat Out Of Hell - Meat Loaf
• Beautiful - Scarling
• Beautiful Freak - Eels
• Beautiful Love - The Afters
• Bed of Nails - Alice Cooper
• Behind Blue Eyes - Limp Bizkit
• Better Together - Jack Johnson
• Blue Would Still Be Blue - The Guillemots
• Bones - The Killers
• Born to Quit - The Used
• The Boy Who Blocked His Own Shot - Brand New
• Break Myself - Something Corporate
• Breakeven - The Script
• Buried Myself Alive - The Used
• Burning Our Bed - Alice Cooper
• Call Me - Blondie
• Calling Your Name - Diamond Heads
• Can’t Get Enough - Bad Company
• Can’t Take My Eyes Off You - Muse
• Catholic Knees - Taking Back Sunday
• Chains - The Cruxshadows
• Chasing Cars - Natasha Beddingfield
• Closer - Nine Inch Nails
• Colorblind - Counting Crows
• Come Around - Counting Crows
• Cosmic Love - Florence + The Machine
• Cross Oceans - First Aid Kit
• Cruel Summer - Karen Elson
• Dance Inside - The All-American Rejects
• Delicate - Damien Rice
• A Design For Life - Manic Street Preachers
• Die For You - Alice Cooper
• Dismantle. Repair. - Anberlin
• Do You Want The Truth Or Something Beautiful - Paloma Faith
• Drops Of Jupiter - Train
• Earthquake - Little Boots
• Electric Twist - A Fine Frenzy
• Even Angels Fall - Vanessa Carlton
• Ever Fallen In Love - Pete Yorn
• The Everlasting - Manic Street Preachers
• Falling Is Like This - Ani DiFranco
• Falling Slowly - Glen Hansard
• Famous Last Words - My Chemical Romance
• Fearless - Taylor Swift
• Feathery Wings - Voltaire
• Feel The Tide Turning - Mumford And Sons
• Fill My Little World - The Feeling
• FNT - Semisonic
• Gay - Stephen Lynch
• Get Me Through - Daughtry
• God Gave Me You - Dave Barnes
• Hallelujah - Jeff Buckley
• Halo - Beyonce OR Florence + the Machine
• Hands Down - Dashboard Confessionals
• Heavy In Your Arms - Florence + The Machine
• Hell Is Here - Saves The Day
• Hello - Poe
• Hey Pretty - Poe
• House of Wolves - My Chemical Romance
• How Can I Tell You - Cat Power
• I’ll Stop The World And Melt With You - The Cure
• I’m Only Me When I’m With You - Taylor Swift
• I’m Yours - The Script
• I Can’t Take My Eyes Off You - Melanie Doane
• I Hate The Way - Polly Scattergood
• I See You, You See Me - The Magic Numbers
• I Touch Myself - Divinyls
• I Will Follow You Into The Dark - Death Cab For Cutie
• If The World Ends - The Guillemots
• Innocent - Taylor Swift
• Into My Arms - Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
• Iris - Goo Goo Dolls
• It’s All In Your Mind - Beck
• It’s All Over Now Baby Blue - Van Morrison
• Just Like Heaven - The Cure
• Just Say Yes - Snow Patrol
• The Kill (Bury Me) - 30 Seconds to Mars
• Kiss With A Fist - Florence + The Machine
• Lemon Meringue - Poe
• Letter to God - Hole
• Life After You - Daughtry
• Like A Prayer - Madonna
• Lips Like Sugar - Echo & The Bunnymen
• Lost In Green Eyes - The Panics
• Louder - Vermillion Lies
• Love It When You Call - The Feeling
• Love You Out Loud - Meat Loaf
• Lovesong - Voltaire
• Lullaby (Goodnight, My Angel) - Billy Joel
• Made Up Love Song #43 - The Guillemots
• Maps - Yeah Yeah Yeahs
• Might As Well Be On Mars - Alice Cooper
• Misery Business - Paramore
• The Moth - Aimee Mann
• My Fairweather Friend - Emilie Autumn
• My Immortal - Evanescence
• My Legs Are Weak - Paloma Faith
• My Sweet Prince - Placebo
• The Noose - A Perfect Circle
• Nothing Else Matters - Metallica
• Nothing Lasts Forever - Echo & The Bunnymen
• Number 1 - Goldfrapp
• The Other Side Of The Door - Taylor Swift
• Out of Time - A Day to Remember
• Perfect - The Smashing Pumpkins
• Please Please Please Let Me Get What I Want - The Smiths
• Poison - Alice Cooper
• Pour Some Sugar On Me - Def Leppard
• Rapture - Hurt
• The Reason - Hoobastank
• Remember Me - The Birthday Massacre
• Sad But True - Metallica
• Save You - Emilie Autumn
• Save Your Goodbye - Mike Posner
• Saw Something - Dave Gahan
• Secret Service - Kansas
• Send Me An Angel - Skid Row
• The Ship Song - Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
• Sick Hearts - The Used
• Shook Me All Night Long - AC/DC
• Silver Lining - Rilo Kiley
• Six Hours - Alice Cooper
• Sleeping Beauty - A Perfect Circle
• Son Of A Preacher Man - Dusty Springfield
• Soulmates - Placebo

• Sparks Fly - Taylor Swift
• Starlight - Muse
• Starving Your Friends - Envy On The Coast
• Stolen Prayer - Alice Cooper
• The Story - Brandi Carlile
• Sunshine Of Your Love - Cream
• Swallow Me - Skid Row
• Sweet Thing - Van Morrison
• Take It Like A Man - Dragonette
• Talk Dirty To Me - Poison
• Thank You - Led Zeppelin
• That’s Okay - The Hush Sound
• There Is A Light That Never Goes Out - The Smiths
• Thirty-Three - Smashing Pumpkins
• This Day Last Year - The Panics
• Tiger In The Night - Katie Melua
• To You I Bestow - Mundy
• Touched - Vast
• Undisclosed Desires - Muse
• Walk Away - Franz Ferdinand
• What I Really Meant To Say - Cyndi Thompson
• What I Wouldn’t Do - A Fine Frenzy
• Wherever You Will Go - The Calling
• Wicked Game - Chuck Isaak
• Wild Horses - The Sundays
• Winter - The Dodos
• You Belong With Me - Taylor Swift
• You Could Be Happy - Snow Patrol
• You Found Me - The Fray
• You Give Love A Bad Name - Bon Jovi
• You Picked Me - A Fine Frenzy
• You Took The Words Right Out Of My Mouth - Meat Loaf
• Your Biggest Mistake - Ellie Goulding
• Your Love Alone Is Not Enough - Manic Street Preachers
• 4am - Our Lady Peace